The NCUA has just issued this
media release which states that the State of Michigan on February 16th has placed
Huron River Area Credit Union into Conservatorship under the NCUA.
This is of particular interest since Huron River Area CU has been advertising 6% CDs for the last several months (see
my last Huron post). It's a moderate size credit union with $348.8 million in assets and 39,318 members. Also, their easy
field of membership has allowed many people outside of Michigan to join.
So what does this mean? The Credit Union National Association had an
article regarding a past conservatorship action by the NCUA. In that article, it states:
Conservatorship means NCUA will run the credit union in an attempt to restore its safety and soundness and return it to members.
I also found the following information about conservatorship in this
CUNA document (doc) regarding pending federal legislation:
NCUA's conservatorship authority, originally granted in the Garn-St Germain Act of 1982, has proven to be an effective administrative tool in ensuring the safety and soundness of credit unions. It permits the agency to freeze an institution's activities and there-by prevents a dissipation of assets. Conservatorship is particularly valuable where publicity may trigger substantial withdrawals and thus endanger the soundness of the credit union. In some cases obtaining control of a credit union's operations and assets has precluded criminal officials, from tampering with or destroying records of their activities. It is also beneficial where the true causes of a credit union's problems are not easily learned. By taking control of the credit union to examine the nature of the credit union's problems, the Committee expects that the interests of all concerned will be best protected. If problems are not sufficient to warrant liquidation, it allows the NCUA Board the flexibility to work with credit union personnel to reopen the institution while at the same time preserving its integrity.
In short, NCUA will assume the management of the credit union. Here are some possible outcomes: 1) It may be merged into a stronger credit union, 2) The safety and soundness issues may be resolved by the NCUA management, and the credit union will be handed back to the members, or 3) If there are problems too severe to resolve, it could be liquidated. NCUA would ensure all insured deposits are returned to members.
It'll be interesting to see if the 6% CD deals and easy membership continue. Perhaps they'll need those promotions to keep deposits. I guess it'll be up to the NCUA management.
Some experienced readers made some good suggestions for members of Huron (which applies to members of any credit union). First, make sure your deposits are under the NCUA insurance limits (see
post). Second, make sure you keep good account records. One reader mentioned the problems he had when his old credit union was merged into a new one and the records weren't fully transferred. He had to bring in original records to resolve the issue.
This incident also points out the advantage of NCUA membership. Some credit unions like Patelco are not NCUA insured and only have private insurance through
American Share Insurance. As we see in this case, the NCUA does more than just provide insurance. It also takes actions like conservatorships to reduce incidents of credit union failures. I'm not sure how much ASI does in this respect.
It's interesting to see what financial ratings Huron River Area Credit Union has received. One problem with ratings is that it's often based on data that can be several months old. For example, the current ratings are based on September 30, 2006 financial data.
BauerFinancial gives Huron 5 out of 5 stars (superior).
Bankrate.com gives Huron 3 out of 5 stars (performing) with a G status which designates high growth. A reader also noticed this growth in Huron's financial data mentioning that it had grown from $252M to $363M in the last year which seems unusual in Michigan. Also he noted it had been making a lot of loans.
To review more of Huron River Area CU's NCUA status and financial reports, please refer to this
NCUA page. Thanks to the readers who noted this NCUA action and provided their experience on this issue.
Labels: banking news, Huron River Area CU, Michigan